Religious Zionist Leader Porush Condemns Left Wing Jewish Groups

July 17, 2009

“We must publicly condemn those Jews who meddle in the White House and betray Eretz Yisrael’s interests” stated Zionist Deputy Education Minister Rabbi Meir Porush in reference to left-wing lobbyists in Washington, such a J Street. Porush condemned those who are working to persuade US President Barak Obama to remove Jews from their homes in the West Bank.

He emphasized that the Israeli left is there to assist them in their efforts, and former Labor MK Colette Avital, who was the Consul-General in NYC, is their official advisor, working to advance their left-wing political agenda.

Rabbi Porush stated that J Street is motivated by “self-hate”, the daily HaMevaser reports, spreading beyond the borders of the United States, to the UK for example, operating under the banner Jews for Justice for Palestinians, working in earnest to have Israel Ministry of Tourism ads removed, working against Israel’s interests. They claim the ads must be removed because the map of Israel shown contains the West Bank, which is contrary to their agenda.

He blames them for the damaging reports against Israeli soldiers in the foreign media, the result of their false accusations. He goes on to explain the source of the ‘tuma’ is undoubtedly the Israeli Peace Now organization, now engaged in an unprecedented battle to remove yishuvim from Yehuda and Shomron. He adds that Peace Now is the ideological source of the lobbyists abroad, such as J Street, adding it is a known fact that Peace Now enjoys funding from a number of foreign governments, some hostile to Israel.

Our comment:

Rabbi Porush conveniently confined his comments to secular Jewish groups, whom he can accuse of “self-hate”. However, he chooses to ignore the Orthodox anti-Zionist world, whose leaders are also “betraying” the Zionist state’s interest. See Kiryas Joel mayor Abraham Wieder’s letter to President Obama, in which he supports the President’s “noble efforts” to stop the “senseless bloodshed” in the Middle East. He says that the Zionists state stands in contravention of the Almighty’s decree, and that the bloodshed is due to the state’s efforts to hold onto a piece of land occupied by its enemies.

Rabbi Porush feebly attempts to cover up his Zionism by calling the Zionist state “Eretz Yisroel” – a term used in traditional Torah texts to refer to the Holy Land regardless of whose rulership it is under. We respectfully ask him to call a spade a spade. If he wishes to be a Zionist, let him accuse his opponents of “undermining the interests of Zionism.”

No one can claim that Orthodox Jews, who believe that saving lives is of the highest priority and supercedes the commandments of the Torah, are self-hating. Anyone who has visited traditionally religious and Hasidic communities knows the tremendous amount of charity work and concern for fellow Jews that exists. So when we speak out against the militant Zionist settlers, it is that same concern for our fellow Jews that motivates us.

Note also, Rabbi Porush, that there is nothing new about our statements that the settlers endanger Jewish lives for the save of a false ideology. Rabbi Elazar M. Shach, whom you respect highly, said the same thing many years ago.

“The idea of settling is simply starting up with the nations of the world, and it comes from the fundamental error of the Zionists, who think that all that has ever befallen us is because we did not have a state and Jewish sovereignty, but now that we are a state equal with all the states of the world, if we show strength and do not budge, our enemies will back away. Even if there are many who adhere to these views, it is a departure from the path we have received from our Sages, and the opposite is the truth.” (Mictavim Umaamarim 2:4)

The opposite – that showing strength and not budging will only lead to further loss of life – is the truth, according to Rabbi Shach. The settlers are endangering our people.

And decades earlier, in 1937 when the idea of a Jewish state was first officially brought on the agenda, Rabbi Yitzchok Zev Soloveitchik, the Brisker Rav, stated clearly:

“In our holy Torah, it makes no difference what character this Jewish state will have. Even if it would be a Jewish state run completely according to the Torah law, even if the president and prime minister would be Reb Chaim Ozer, and everything would be done according to the Torah – even then it is forbidden that even one Jew be killed in order to establish a Jewish state. That is the crux of the issue here. The issue is not how the Jewish state will be run, religiously or secularly. The point is that it is forbidden for Jewish blood to be spilled for the purpose of establishing a Jewish state. And since it is impossible to accomplish the partition without spilling Jewish blood, it is forbidden to accept this plan.”

Jews live in a confusing time, a time when one can see very religious Jews such as Rabbi Porush speaking out against the dismantling of the settlements. We are told to cry for the poor Jewish homes that are being cruelly uprooted, the yeshivos and shuls that will be plowed to the ground. But we are being told to forget the fact that the settlers are there for a specific purpose. There is a reason why they do not live in New York or Chicago or London. They are there to fight, to anger the Palestinians, and thus to put their lives – and all Jewish lives – on the line for the sake of their ideals. And the Brisker Rav taught us that this is wrong. These people are the most dangerous rodfim – pursuers and threats - to the Jewish people. We should rejoice when something is finally being done to hold them back and dislodge them from their positions.

Of course, we know that even this is not enough, and that the entire Zionist state, as a rebellion against G-d, cannot ultimately be successful. The Torah teaches us that Jews will not be safe as long as it exists.